Clock blocked. (Photo credit: Jackson Lewis)
Is a Rolex still a Rolex if the movement and case are from the brand, but the bezel was swapped with a diamond-studded bezel not made by Rolex? What if the dial is genuine but repainted using non-Rolex methods — or simply embellished with diamonds?
An appeals court on Friday published a decision in a lawsuit filed by Rolex Watch U.S.A., a subsidiary of Geneva-based Rolex Holding S.A., against Texas-based watch dealer BeckerTime. It affirmed the lower court that parts replaced, such as the bezel, dial, and bracelet, “are integral and necessary,” and therefore BeckerTime infringed on Rolex’s trademarks despite dealer's disclosures to customers.
The lawsuit was filed against BeckerTime just months after Rolex U.S.A. won its case against La Californienne, in 2020. The case against BeckerTime was cross-appealed last year and reaffirmed on Friday, a potential death knell for Rolex customizers and their dealers in the U.S.
One setback for Rolex U.S.A.: the court says while repainted dials constitute copyright infringements, embellished dials with added diamonds or stones “not involving the removal or reapplication of Rolex’s trademarks” do not.